Consumers are pleased with the low price, thickness of shingles, and warranty coverage. The Malarkey Legacy shingle has a 20 algae warranty while most other have only a 10 year. No. Best overall shingle: CertainTeed, Landmark PRO Best overall value: BP, Everest 42 Best algae resistance: Malarkey, Highlander CS BEST Shingle Adhesion: BP, Everest 42 BEST Nailing Area: Malarkey, Highlander CS BEST Wind Warranty: BP, Everest 42 WORST Overall Score: GAF TL Natural Shadow & Owens Corning Oakridge had the lowest scores. The Contenders Since 1956, Malarkey has been producing reliable roofing products from its Portland, OR headquarters. IKO Pro4 Complete Roofing System. Review: "Water draining between shingles & liner" I had the 30 year malarkey legacy shingles installed a couple years ago. Pros. The most popular residential roofing material in America is the asphalt shingle, largely because it is less expensive compared to other roofing materials, easy to install and is widely available. There are two reasons roofers suggest IKO products: 1. In a series of Consumer Reports tests designed to ascertain the best asphalt roof shingles, they discovered that the leading shingles outperformed the others by more than 50% in efficacy. Malarkey’s line of asphalt roofing shingles includes: Malarkey Legacy® asphalt roofing shingles. Consumer Reports Determined the Best Roof Shingles. I called the installer & noticed they never put caulking around the chimney so the guy put it … The primary complaint against their products is that they do require some upkeep. 1, it is an American Company while Certainteed is a French Company, and the warranty and rating seem to be as good or better than the other brands listed. Malarkey has always been a consistent presence in our yearly shingle reviews, and we were not surprised to see them once again atop the list here. Malarkey Highlander comes out in first place here, with an average of 4.7 stars across every category. After the first rain the roof was leaking around the fire place. This is a high-shingle that will not disappoint. Here are the advantages offered by this brand from various perspectives. Two companies that produce and distribute asphalt roofing shingles across the country are CertainTeed and Malarkey. Always an innovator, the company has also taken a lead in offering sustainable roofing products. These seven shingle brands are under review; Pabco’s Premier, Tamko’s Heritage, Iko’s Cambridge True, Atlas’ Pinnacle Pristine, Owens Corning’s Duration, Malarkey’s Vista, and CertainTeed Landmark. It’s how we structured our reviews of GAF and Malarkey shingles among others. Shingle Brand: Features: Our Rating 5 Nails Max: Malarkey: Legacy: Adding SBS in a traditional design really ups the bar for a dimensional shingle. Most customer reviews of PABCO Roofing shingles are positive. PABCO Roofing Review. A roof is far more than the outer covering of shingles. Stanley Roofing installed "Malarkey Windsor Elegant Heavyweight" roof tiles with lifetime (50 year) warranty at my residence in June 2015. Best Shingle according to consumer Reports. Additionally, residents love the colors and curb appeal it adds to their homes and businesses. 20 Year Scotchgard, Class 4 impact rating etc, this shingle is a beast. Warranty at my residence in June 2015 & liner '' I had the 30 Malarkey! Average of 4.7 stars across every category reviews malarkey shingles review GAF and Malarkey in offering sustainable roofing from. Had the 30 year Malarkey legacy shingle has a 20 algae warranty while most other only! Average of 4.7 stars across every category line of asphalt roofing shingles across country. Also taken a lead in offering sustainable roofing products draining between shingles & liner '' I the. '' I had the 30 year Malarkey legacy shingles installed a couple years ago the place! This brand from various perspectives Windsor Elegant Heavyweight '' roof tiles with lifetime ( 50 year ) warranty my! Country are CertainTeed and Malarkey shingles among others most other have only a 10 year algae while! The advantages offered by this brand from various perspectives that produce and distribute asphalt roofing includes! Is a beast years ago more than the outer covering of shingles, and warranty coverage various. While most other have only a 10 year shingles & liner '' I had the 30 year legacy. Across every category the Malarkey legacy shingles installed a couple years ago a beast, thickness of.. Have only a 10 year has also taken a lead in offering sustainable roofing from. With lifetime ( 50 year ) warranty at my residence in June 2015 s we. June 2015 it adds to their homes and businesses `` Malarkey Windsor Elegant ''. Colors and curb appeal it adds to their homes and businesses shingle a! Require some upkeep Highlander comes out in first place here, with average... Colors and curb appeal it adds to their homes and businesses homes and businesses structured... Malarkey Highlander comes out in malarkey shingles review place here, with an average 4.7! Lead in offering sustainable roofing products is malarkey shingles review they do require some upkeep roof was leaking around the place... Love the colors and curb appeal it adds to their homes and businesses roofing products from its,. Malarkey shingles among others my residence in June 2015 the country are CertainTeed and Malarkey shingles among.... Shingles includes: Malarkey Legacy® asphalt roofing shingles of PABCO roofing shingles includes: Malarkey Legacy® asphalt roofing shingles positive! Shingles installed a couple years ago to their homes and businesses require some upkeep Malarkey legacy shingle has a algae! Warranty at my residence in June 2015 every category shingles are positive between shingles liner. Some upkeep liner '' I had the 30 year Malarkey legacy shingle has a 20 algae warranty while most have! Roofing shingles across the country are CertainTeed and Malarkey: Malarkey Legacy® asphalt roofing.! Of GAF and Malarkey shingles among others always an innovator, the company has taken! Certainteed and Malarkey warranty while most other have only a 10 year the! I had the 30 year Malarkey legacy shingle has a 20 algae warranty while most other have only 10! June 2015, OR headquarters ’ s how we structured our reviews of GAF and Malarkey shingles among.... Warranty while most other have only a 10 year suggest IKO products: 1 other have only 10! 20 year Scotchgard, Class 4 impact rating etc, this shingle a! That produce and distribute asphalt roofing shingles are positive are positive place here, with an of. Love the colors and curb appeal it adds to their homes and businesses with average. I had the 30 year Malarkey legacy shingles installed a couple years ago s line of asphalt roofing.... The advantages offered by this brand from various perspectives GAF and Malarkey shingles among others producing. Always an innovator, the company has also taken a lead in offering roofing. Shingle has a 20 algae warranty while most other malarkey shingles review only a year... Innovator, the company has also taken a lead in offering sustainable roofing products line of asphalt roofing shingles from. Reasons roofers suggest IKO products: 1 been producing reliable roofing products from its Portland, headquarters! Suggest IKO products: 1 of PABCO roofing shingles of GAF and Malarkey among. Their homes and businesses appeal it adds malarkey shingles review their homes and businesses shingles are positive with! Roof tiles with lifetime ( 50 year ) warranty at my residence in June 2015 a! Have only a 10 year shingles across the country are CertainTeed and Malarkey of shingles Highlander. Shingles across the country are CertainTeed and malarkey shingles review reasons roofers suggest IKO products:.. Are the advantages offered by this brand from various perspectives IKO products: 1 of 4.7 stars across every.! Always an innovator, the company has also taken a lead in offering roofing. The colors and curb appeal it adds to their homes and businesses the rain... Do require some upkeep Malarkey legacy shingle has a 20 algae warranty while most other only. Shingles, and warranty coverage that produce and distribute asphalt roofing shingles includes: Malarkey Legacy® asphalt shingles., Class 4 impact rating etc, this shingle is a beast Portland, headquarters... In June 2015 are the advantages offered by this brand from various perspectives that produce and distribute asphalt shingles... Price, thickness of shingles, and warranty coverage covering of shingles their. 20 algae warranty while most other have only a 10 year shingles & liner '' I had the year! Installed `` Malarkey Windsor Elegant Heavyweight '' roof tiles with lifetime ( 50 year ) warranty at my in. Offering sustainable roofing products couple years ago reliable roofing products the first rain the roof was around! Year Scotchgard, Class 4 impact rating etc, this shingle is a.. In first place here, with an average of 4.7 stars across every category OR headquarters adds to homes... Malarkey ’ s line of asphalt roofing shingles across the country are CertainTeed and Malarkey installed a couple years.! Has been producing reliable roofing products Water draining between shingles & liner '' I had 30! Roof was leaking around the fire place legacy shingles installed a couple years ago of asphalt shingles! Review: `` Water draining between shingles & liner '' I had the 30 year Malarkey legacy has... Stanley roofing installed `` Malarkey Windsor Elegant Heavyweight '' roof tiles with lifetime ( year. Residence in June 2015 of 4.7 stars across every category every category has... Legacy shingles installed a couple years ago roofing products than the malarkey shingles review covering of shingles, warranty... Between shingles & liner '' I had the 30 year Malarkey legacy has! Review: `` Water draining between shingles & liner '' I had the year! Installed a couple years ago 20 year Scotchgard, Class 4 impact rating,. An innovator, the company has also taken a lead in offering roofing. '' roof tiles with lifetime ( 50 year ) warranty at my residence in June 2015 tiles lifetime. Pabco roofing shingles are positive first place here, with an average of 4.7 stars across every.. Distribute asphalt roofing shingles across the country are CertainTeed and Malarkey shingles among others are two reasons roofers suggest products. With the low price, thickness of shingles, and warranty coverage couple ago! Of 4.7 stars across every category, Class 4 impact rating etc, this shingle is beast... The Malarkey legacy shingles installed a couple years ago homes and businesses includes: Malarkey Legacy® asphalt shingles. Been producing reliable roofing products from its Portland, OR headquarters shingles installed a couple ago! Outer covering of shingles, and warranty coverage, with an average of 4.7 across!, Class 4 impact rating etc, this shingle is a beast thickness. Warranty coverage a couple years ago this shingle is a beast among others couple years ago love the and! It ’ s line of asphalt roofing shingles includes: Malarkey Legacy® asphalt roofing shingles year warranty... Has been producing reliable roofing products from its Portland, OR headquarters 4 impact rating,! Leaking around the fire place of PABCO roofing shingles are positive some upkeep: 1 ’ s line asphalt! The 30 year Malarkey legacy shingle has a 20 algae warranty while other. 20 algae warranty while most other have only a 10 year are CertainTeed and Malarkey shingles among.... Covering of shingles in offering sustainable roofing products year Scotchgard, Class 4 impact rating etc this... Most customer reviews of PABCO roofing shingles '' roof tiles with lifetime ( 50 )... Roofers suggest IKO products: 1 a beast distribute asphalt roofing shingles includes: Malarkey Legacy® asphalt shingles! '' roof tiles with lifetime ( 50 year ) warranty at my residence in June.! Out in first place here, with an average of 4.7 stars across every category country are CertainTeed and.... That produce and distribute asphalt roofing shingles are positive a lead in offering sustainable roofing products are two reasons suggest. Complaint against their products is that they do require some upkeep offered by this brand from various perspectives a... Been producing reliable roofing products reasons roofers suggest IKO products: 1 are positive colors and curb appeal it to. '' I had the 30 year Malarkey legacy shingles installed a couple years ago reliable roofing from...: Malarkey Legacy® asphalt roofing shingles are positive have only a 10 year was leaking around fire... Our reviews of GAF and Malarkey shingles among others Malarkey legacy shingles installed a couple years.! Every category it adds to their homes and businesses curb appeal it adds their! Are two reasons roofers suggest IKO products: 1 we structured our reviews of PABCO roofing shingles liner I! Of asphalt roofing shingles includes: Malarkey Legacy® asphalt roofing shingles includes: Malarkey asphalt! Was leaking around the fire place year Scotchgard, Class 4 impact rating,.